Citation
Zhang, Xing & Grant, Annaliese (2022). Parent-Child Relationships and Mental Health in the Transition to Adulthood by Race and Ethnicity. Currents: Journal of Diversity Scholarship for Social Change. vol. 2 (1) , PMCID: PMC10010682Abstract
There is growing literature about the positive and moderating roles that parent-child relationships can have for adolescent and adult mental health outcomes. Research has shown, for example, that positive and communicative parent-adolescent relationships significantly predict lower adolescent depressive symptoms and can moderate negative effects of parental conflict in families (Ackard et al., 2006; Morgan et al., 2012; Osborne & Fincham, 1996). Many of these studies use population-level data sets and control for families’ racial and ethnic identity. In doing so, much of this literature implicitly assumes the framework of the standard North American family, allowing the largest population to guide the results and assuming that racial and ethnic identity merely adjusts the relationship between parent-child relationships and adolescent mental health (Smith, 1993). Rather than understanding how emotional and relational aspects of families may function differently by family race and ethnicity, the largest populations are centralized.In addition to large-scale population-based studies, there is also a range of literature about the specific ways that race and ethnicity structure and have meaning for parent-child relationships and family mental health outcomes (Davidson & Cardemil, 2009; Smith & Sun, 2014). Scholars have found that parent-child relationships can moderate the negative effects of racism and discrimination on adolescent mental health for Black families in the United States, that parent-child relationships hold specific gendered meanings for Latinx families where children participate in language brokering for immigrant parents, and that the relationships between family-child relationships and child mental health vary by race and ethnicity (Cooper & McLoyd, 2011; Love & Buriel, 2007; Moon & Rao, 2010).
In this project, we expand on current research about race, parent-child relationships, and adolescent mental health by evaluating race and ethnicity as central structuring forces in family processes rather than using racial identity as a control or assuming that the way white middle-class families live their lives is the “best” or most “normal.” In thinking about race as a structuring force in families (which has negative effects for mental health), this includes acknowledging the role of racism as both a structural force and as an interpersonal reality for families of color. We use stepwise-regression analysis to understand these relationships and focus on what these relationships look like in adulthood.
Research Questions
We address the following research questions: How does mental health vary by race/ethnicity in adulthood? How do parent-child relationships, specifically maternal closeness and living arrangements, shape mental health across race/ethnicity in adulthood?
Methods
Data
To complete the analyses proposed, we use data from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent to Adult Health (Add Health), Waves I, IV, and V. Add Health is a nationally representative, school-based sample of respondents who were in the 7th through 12th grades from 1994–1995 in the United States and were followed until they were ages 32–42 years old in 2016–2018 at Wave V, the most recent Wave of data collection. At Wave IV, respondents were 28–34 years old. More information about the data is available at https://addhealth.cpc.unc.edu/. We restricted the analytic sample to individuals who completed Waves I, IV, and V, had valid cross-sectional sample weights at Wave V, and did not have missing data on the dependent variable, independent variables, and control variables. This led to an analytic sample of 8,970 respondents.
Measures
Dependent Variable
Depressive symptoms at Wave V were based on the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) and included the following items asked of the respondent in the past seven days at the time of interview: “I felt like I could not shake off the blues, even with the help from my family and friends”; “I felt depressed”; “I was happy” (reverse-coded); “I felt sad”; “I felt that life was not worth living.” Items ranged from never or rarely (1) to most of the time or all of the time (4).
Primary Independent Variables of Interest
The primary independent variables of interest included maternal closeness, parent-child living arrangements, and race and ethnicity. Maternal closeness was measured at Wave IV and included the respondent’s answer to the following question: “How close do you feel to your mother figure?” Answers ranged from 1 (not at all close), 2 (not very close), 3 (somewhat close), 4 (quite close), to 5 (very close). Parent-child living arrangements at Wave IV included whether the respondent was living with their parents or not at Wave IV. Race and ethnicity was measured at Wave V and included non-Latinx Black, Latinx, non-Latinx Asian, and non-Latinx white categories.
Controls
We included the following controls, including gender (male or female), maternal education in adolescence (did not graduate high school and less; high school graduate or GED; some college; completed college and more), and family structure in adolescence (two biological parents; two parents; single parent; and other).
Analytic Approach
To complete the analyses, we first conducted weighted summary statistics of the analytic sample. Then, we conducted summary statistics by race and ethnicity for depressive symptoms at Wave V. Finally, we conducted stepwise OLS regressions with the primary independent variables of maternal closeness, living arrangements, race/ethnicity, and control variables to assess associations with depressive symptoms in adulthood (Wave V).
Findings
Summary Statistics
We describe weighted summary statistics of the analytic sample in Table 1. The majority of the sample is white (73%), with 14% being Black, 9% being Latinx, and 3% being Asian. The average respondent age at Wave V is about 38 years old. By Wave IV, the majority of respondents reported a close relationship with their mothers, with an average closeness of 4.52 on a scale from 1 to 5. A noticeable proportion of respondents (15%) live with their parents by Wave IV. By Wave V, respondents have somewhat low depressive symptoms, with an average score of 1.47.
URL
https://doi.org/10.3998/ncidcurrents.1937Keyword(s)
Parent-child relationsReference Type
Journal ArticleJournal Title
Currents: Journal of Diversity Scholarship for Social ChangeAuthor(s)
Zhang, XingGrant, Annaliese